forum SignWriting List Forum
  Message 2734  |  Previous | Next  [ Up Thread ] Message Index
From:  Lourdes Tollette
Date:  Mon Feb 7, 2000  3:11 pm
Subject:  Re: Peoples attitude about SignWriting

Yes, I agree with Val. Same thing I was in Oral school but they are all
deaf student in Boston School for the Deaf in Mass. All Nun agaisnt sign
language but most student like to use sign so we had to hide other room.
They can comucation each other with sign. Around in 1976 Boston School for
the deaf start Total comucation (sign language and talk). I left 1976 and
enrolled Keefe Tech High School in Framingham, Ma (mainstream class). That
H.S allow sign.. I was way over my head but I did alot catch up and meet
deaf club. So Now I am more ASL.

-----Original Message-----
From: Valerie Sutton [SMTP:]
Sent: Monday, February 07, 2000 9:09 AM
To: SignWriting List
Subject: Re: Peoples attitude about SignWriting

Dawn McReynolds wrote:

"Unfortunately I the only point that she seemed to except was how
much it has helped Nicole and her reading and writing level. I
remember when people would look differently at Nicole when we first
starting signing and now almost everyone can fingerspell, there's a
big difference from now and twelve years ago. people are much more
aware and excepting of Deafness then they were even then.. Maybe the
same will happen with Sign Writing." Dawn


SignWriting List
February 7, 2000

Thank you, Dawn, for sharing this story with everyone. When we first
started reading and writing signs back in the late 1970's, people
basically thought we were that kind of a story was "the
normal experience" for us daily.

And you are absolutely correct that time will change the
situation...people need time to think about new ideas. It is a
natural instinct to be wary of new ideas, and maybe that is good.
Your communication with this mother was excellent and she may go home
and think about it, or at least be a little more open-minded about it

I used to say that it always took three discussions before someone
was interested:

1. the first time they are angry and against it
2. the second time they are neutral
3. the third time they are considering it and want to make sure they
have thought it through properly.

Then they become the strongest advocates, because they really thought
about it beforehand.

So I wouldn't let it bother you. One of the reasons that people react
that way, is that deep in their hearts, they have never accepted
American Sign Language or any signed language as "equal to spoken
languages". They may say that they feel ASL is a true language, but
they have never thought of it as "equal to English" in its
sophistication and importance.

And one last are an exceptional mother, Dawn, because you
are taking the time to teach your daughter, and to learn SignWriting
yourself. But that is an investment of time for other mothers, who
may not sign very well themselves. So SignWriting frightens them,
because then they would have to learn it....

So there are many issues here. When people talk to me with anger,
generally this is what I say:

"Of course SignWriting may not be for you, and no one is asking you
to use it. But some people choose to use it, and that is their

Then they relax, because they realize I am not asking them to do anything!

Please say "hello" to your daughter for me, and I wish you all the best -
Val ;-)


Valerie Sutton


SignWriting List Archive

Deaf Action Committee For SignWriting
Box 517, La Jolla, CA, 92038-0517, USA

  Message 2734  |  Previous | Next  [ Up Thread ] Message Index