forum SignWriting List Forum
  Message 270  |  Previous | Next  [ Up Thread ] Message Index
From:  "Angus B. Grieve-Smith"
Date:  Sun Jul 19, 1998  11:41 pm
Subject:  Re: Menu question

Sorry this is a few days late. I had trouble sending it off and
then had to go out of town.

Valerie Sutton wrote:

> In the Preferences Box you can also choose:
> Menus in Signs
> Menus in Signs and Words
> Menus in Words
> So...if you choose "Menus in Words" and your country is USA, then the words
> will be in English, such as File, Edit, Cut, Copy, Paste etc. If your
> country is Spain, the words will be in Spanish, etc. In this beta testing
> version, we will start with English, but add the other 8 spoken languages
> as soon as everything seems to be working well.

Valerie, I think it's a great idea to have the menus available
in signs. Too many people have the unconscious assumption that the
only way to discuss signs is in a spoken language.

I have one concern: to me, a sign is a "word" just like words
in spoken languages, only signed. I think maybe "menus in spoken
language" would be better.

Also, rather than arranging it by country, it might be better
just to have the menus available in any of the languages supported by
SignWriter. For example, I know a hearing American whose two best
languages are English and Mexican Sign Language (LSM). Why should he
need to know Spanish in order to use SignWriter? Similarly, there may
be native ASL signers who want to write BSL, but would rather have the
menus in ASL.

So instead of having to choose from a list with only two
languages on it (once the other countries are supported), a user would
be able to choose any two languages from the fifteen signed and eight
spoken languages available. Can this be done?

-Angus B. Grieve-Smith
Linguistics Department
University of New Mexico

  Replies Author Date
271 "Signs" & "Words" Valerie Sutton Mon  7/20/1998
275 Re: Menu question Valerie Sutton Wed  7/22/1998

  Message 270  |  Previous | Next  [ Up Thread ] Message Index