forum SignWriting List Forum
  Message 632  |  Previous | Next  [ Up Thread ] Message Index
From:  Valerie Sutton
Date:  Thu Dec 3, 1998  5:26 am
Subject:  Re: Silent News Columnist Seeking Some Feedback

>Well, I did it again! I would really like to answer the questions from
>SILENT NEWS regarding SignWriting, but I deleted the file with the
>Valerie, can you resend, please?
>-- James

Hi James! Here they are:

From: Alexandra Han
To: SignWriting List

Hi Everyone.

Here are the questions which I promised in my last e-mail. I'm a
columnist for Silent News, and those of you who are responding to a couple
of these questions or so, I'd appreciate it if you could respond by
Thursday morning, or Friday a.m. at the latest, so I could incorporate the
information into the article.

Again, don't worry about perfect grammar, etc. I'm used to reading
English, I read it all the time!! :-)


Alexandra M.

1) What role(s) do you think SignWriting is playing in Deaf and hard of
hearing children's education? Can you give specific examples?

2) Several schools for the Deaf are participating in this SignWriting
program. If you are participating in such a program, it may be too early
to tell as yet, but is there any evidence that SignWriting has contributed
in any way to your students' ability to read and write in English? (If any
articles have been printed showing that statistically SignWriting does
contribute, please let me know!)

3) Does SignWriting still face continuing controversy, ridicule,
etc even today? From what sources, usually? (i.e., Deaf people/leaders,
hearing people, administrators of deaf schools, etc). What is(are) the most
common argument(s) against SignWriting?

4) What do you usually say in response to their argument(s) against

5) Won't the rapid pace of technology, including Internet technology,
simply wipe SignWriting out, reducing it obsolete? Why or why not? After
all, videocameras (useful for signed ASL) are shrinking rapidly in both
size and cost, as are computer chips, and new technology is continually
popping up to replace old ways of doing things.

6) What flaws does SignWriting and/or its software still have that
to be worked out? (Since you are all obviously proponents of SignWriting,
I expect positive comments in general; however, every program has its
kinks that it needs to work out, and SignWriting is no exception! :-) )

7) What is this new profession, "Sign Language Journalism", and
how many
Deaf and/or hearing reporters are in this particular field in North America
and/or the rest of the world, that you know of? And how many readers are
there, approximately, who read materials written in this way?

8) As you well know, D/hoh children must learn to write, take speech
therapy, and learn ASL if they are in a Deaf school or a Bi-Bi program. Now
you're asking these children to learn yet another form of language: the
written version of ASL. One argument that could be made against
SignWriting is that it's even more work for these children AND their
teachers, and thus reducing the time for learning written English, which
the children need. What is your response?

9) Have other people tried to put their own, spoken (not signed)
into a written form in the past? How did it work?

Again, you DON'T have to answer every one of these questions! Just
pick a
couple or so, and any experience you share with me would be greatly

In advance, thanks for any information you can share,

Alexandra M.

Valerie :-)

Valerie Sutton at the DAC
Deaf Action Committee for SW


Center For Sutton Movement Writing
an educational nonprofit organization
Box 517, La Jolla, CA, 92038-0517, USA

  Replies Author Date
642 Re: Silent News Columnist Seeking Some Feedback Judy Kegl Fri  12/4/1998
668 Higher Resolution Symbols Online Valerie Sutton Thu  12/10/1998
706 Dreams for SW Valerie Sutton Wed  12/16/1998

  Message 632  |  Previous | Next  [ Up Thread ] Message Index